MACP on Promotional Hierarchy – Supreme Court Case Status – Order reserved
MACP ON PROMOTIONAL HIERARCHY
Supreme Court Case No 21803/2014
Updates of today’s/Final hearing-
Advocate C K Sasi (AOR), who was well briefed by us, argued the case for M V Mohanan Nair. Advocates, representing to other respondents also done commendable job. Actually it was a well organised team work. Amicus Curiae presented the case extremely well. He also submitted a written statement of his arguments to the court. As a result, the court realized the following:
1) There are anomalies in MACP scheme as evident from Minutes of Meeting of Anomaly Committee.
2) These anomalies are affecting Group B & C employees and no impact on Group A.
3) These anomalies have life long impact.
Arguments have been completed and the case is now reserved for orders. We expect a judgment allowing MACP on promotional hierarchy.
Thanks
for Steering Committee
MACP on Promotional hierarchy
Case Status from Supreme Court Website:-
Diary No.- 14117 – 2014
UNION OF INDIA SECRETARY vs. M.V. MOHANAN NAIR
| Diary No. | 14117/2014 Filed on 24-04-2014 06:10 PM
PENDING [SECTION: XI-A] |
| Case No. | SLP(C) No. 021803 / 2014 Registered on 08-08-2014 S.L.P.(C)…CC No. 008271 / 2014 Registered on 21-05-2014 |
| Present/Last Listed On | 23-01-2020 [HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE R. BANUMATHI, HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. BOPANNA and HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE HRISHIKESH ROY] [CL.NO. : 101] |
| Status/Stage | Pending – (Final Hearing) Heard & Reserved-Ord dt:23-01-2020 |
| Admitted | [ADMITTED ON : 30-07-2019] |
| Category | 1900-Three Judges Bench Matter |
| Act | |
| Petitioner(s) | 1 UNION OF INDIA .DEPT OF PERSONNEL AND TRAINING SECRETARY SECRETARY MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL PUBLIC GRIEVANCES AND PENSION , DISTRICT: NEW DELHI ,NEW DELHI , DELHI2 THE PRINCIPAL REGISTRAR CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, PRINCIPAL BENCH, 61/35, COPERNICUS MARG , DISTRICT: NEW DELHI ,NEW DELHI , DELHI3 KERALA CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL THE DEPUTY REGISTRAR ERNAKULAM BENCH , , DISTRICT: KOCHIN ,ERNAKULAM , KERALA |
| Respondent(s) | 1 M.V. MOHANAN NAIR S/D/W/Thru:- M.R VISHWANATHAN NAIR PHOTO COPIER, CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL , DISTRICT: ERNAKULAM KOCHIN ,ERNAKULAM , KERALA |
| Pet. Advocate(s) | ARVIND KUMAR SHARMA[P-2]
ARVIND KUMAR SHARMA[P-1] ARVIND KUMAR SHARMA[P-3] MUKESH KUMAR MARORIA |
| Resp. Advocate(s) | C. K. SASI
G. PRAKASH |
| Impleaders Advocate(s) | MOHAN KUMAR[IMPL] |
| Intervenor Advocate(s) | M. K. DUA[INT]
RAMESHWAR PRASAD GOYAL[INT] SATISH KUMAR[INT] |
COMMENTS