Status of Cadre Review Proposal processed in DoPT upto October, 2018
A. Approved by Cabinet – 28
B. Pending Proposals – 20
1. With Concerned Ministry – CRC meeting held and Cabinet approval pending – 9
2. With Cabinet Secretariat – 0
3. With Department of Personnel & Training – 6
4. With Department of Expenditure – 3
5. With Ministry concerned for clarifications – 2
Status of Cadre Review proposals processed in DoPT
from1st January, 2011 to 31st October, 2018
A. Approved by Cabinet
| S. No. | Name of the Service | CRC* Meeting | Cabinet Approval |
| 1. | CPWD Central Engineering Service, Central Electrical & Mechanical Engineering Service and Central Architecture Service | 27-06-2011 | 03-01-2012 |
| 2. | Military Engineering Services (Indian Defence Service of Engineers,Architect Cadre and Surveyor Cadre) | 22/09/2011and 23/01/2012 | 18-04-2013 |
| 3. | Indian Revenue Service | 19/02/2013 and GoM** on 29/04/2013 | 23-05-2013 |
| 4. | Indian Radio Regulatory Service | 19-02-2013 | 03-07-2013 |
| 5. | Central Labour Service | 19-02-2013 | 17-07-2013 |
| 6. | Indian Customs & Central Excise | 27-08-2013 | 05-12-2013 |
| 7. | Indian Cost Accounts Service | 29-10-2013 | 02-01-2014 |
| 8. | Central Power Engineering Service | 11-12-2013 | 13-05-2014 |
| 9. | Indian Ordnance Factory Service | 19-03-2014 | 29-10-2014 |
| 10. | Indian Civil Accounts Service | 17-07-2013 | 16-01-2015 |
| 11. | Border Road Engineering Service | 26-02-2015 | 07-04-2015 |
| 12. | Defence Aeronautical Quality Assurance Service | 08-01-2015 | 06-05-2015 |
| 13. | Indian Trade Service | 06-05-2014 | 01-07-2015 |
| 14. | Indian Statistical Service | 24-06-2014 | 29-07-2015 |
| 15. | Indian Skill Development Service | 10-04-2015 | 07/10/2015 |
| 16. | Indian Postal Service | 28-12-2015 | 25-05-2016 |
| 17. | Central Reserve Police Force | 15-12-2015 | 29-06-2016 |
| 18. | Indian Information Service | 05-05-2016 | 24-08-2016 |
| 19. | Border Security Force | 29-06-2016 | 12-09-2016 |
| 20 . | Indian P & T Accounts and Finance Service | 17-09-2015 | 27-10-2016 |
| 21. | Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME) Indian Enterprise Development Service (IEDS) |
28-12-2015 | 21-12-2016 |
| 22. | Indian Telecom Service | 06-10-2016 | 21-12-2016 |
| 23 . | Central Engineering Service (Roads) | 25/04/20 16 | 06-03-2017 |
| 24. | Indian Naval Material Management Service | 24/ 10/2013 | 22-06-2017 |
| 25. | Indian Defence Accounts Service | 09-09-2016 | 19-07-2017 |
| 26. | Sashastra Seema Bal (SSS) (Group ‘A’ Combatised) | 19.7.2017 | 20.12.2017 |
| 27. | Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) | 15.05 .2017 | 10.01.2018 |
| 28. | Indian Petroleum and Explosive Safety Service (IPESS) | 09.01.2017 | 02.05.2018 |
* CRC – Cadre Review Committee
** GoM – Group of Ministers
B. Pending Proposals
| SI. No. | Name of the Service |
Status
|
| 1. With Concerned Ministry – CRC meeting held and Cabinet approval pending (9) , | ||
| 1. | Indian Railways Personnel Service | Meeting of CRC was held on 19.04.2018 . Approvals of MoS (PP) and FM have been obtained. MoR moved the Draft Cabinet Note. MoR has been asked to revise the DCN. |
| 2. | Indian Railways Traffic Service | -do- |
| 3. | Indian Railways Stores Service | -do- |
| 4. | Indian Railways Accounts Service | -do- |
| 5. | Indian Railways Service of Mechanical Engineers | -do- |
| 6. | Indian Railways Service of Electrical Engineers | -do- |
| 7. | Indian Railways Service of Engineers | -do- |
| 8. | Indian Railways Service of Signal Engineers | -do- |
| 9. | Railway Protection Force | Request of MoR to submit a revised proposal has been acceded to by DoPT. They were advised to submit the revised proposal within a month i.e. June, 2018. Revised cadre review proposal is awaited. Reminder has been sent on 25.09.2018 |
| 2. With Cabinet Secretariat (0) | ||
| 3. With Department of Personnel & Training (6) | ||
| 10. | Indian Ordnance Factories Health Services (IOFHS) | The approval of Secretary (Exp) has been obtained. Note for CRC has been sent to Cabinet Secretariat on 25.09.2018. Meeting of CRC was held on 15.10.2018. Necessary consultation as per directions of CRC are being taken. |
| 11. | Survey of India Group ‘A’ | The cadre review proposal has been received in DoPT which is under consideration. |
| 12. | Indian Economic Service | DEA has been requested for certain clarifications which have been received and are under consideration. |
| 13. | Indian P&T Building Works | Approval of Secretary (Exp) has been obtained. Note for CRC has been considered in CRC meeting held on 30.08.2018. Minutes of the meeting have been forwarded to DoT to provide necessary inputs |
| 14. | Indian Supply Service | The proposal is under examination in consultation with various division of DoPT |
| 15. | Indian Inspection Service | The proposal is under examination in consultation with various division of DoPT |
| 4. With Department of Expenditure (2) | ||
| 16. | Indian Armament Naval Service (INAS) | DoE has sought certain clarifications. Reply of MoD has been received which has been sent to DoE on 04.09.2018 . |
| 17. | Indo Tibetan Border Police (ITBP) | Recommendations of DoPT have been sent to DoE for approval of Secretary (Exp) on 24.08 .2018 . |
| 18. | Indian Defence Estate Service (IDES) | Recommendations of DoPT have been sent to DoE for approval of Secretary (Exp) in the last week of Oct., 2018 |
| 5. With Ministry concerned for clarifications (2) | ||
| 19. | Indian Medical Railway Service (IRMS) | Proposal was found incomplete. MoR has been requested to send the complete proposal. Reminder has been sent on 28.09.2018 |
| 20. | Central Health Service (CHS) | Proposal was found incomplete. MoFHW has been requested to send the complete proposal. Reminder has been sent on 28.09.2018 |
Note: A calendar of cadre review has been issued vide OM No.1-11019/9/2018-CRD dated 25.05.2018 . The name of the Service/Cadre along with the month by which cadre review proposal is required to be submitted to DoPT is mentioned in the Annexure . The aforesaid OM dated 25.05 .2018 is available on the official website of DoPT i.e. www.dopt.gov .in (Link: Notifications -> OMs & Orders -> Cadre Review Division -> General Circulars). The Cadre Controlling Authority may take immediate action for compliance.
COMMENTS
OROP is now applicable only to Defense personnel. What is the harm if this is given to Civil employees also.